Review: ‘Brothers By Blood’

Crime capers are almost always about spectacle. Huge set-pieces consisting of gunfights, robberies, car chases and knife fights. The bigger in scale, the better. So what happens when a crime caper has none of the above? No spectacle, no set-pieces, next-to-no action? For the answer, look no further than Brothers By Blood, the latest film from French writer and director Jérémie Guez, an impressively acted if overall ineffective low-key crime drama / thriller that is heavy on the drama and light on the thrills.

Brothers By Blood, known in other territories as The Sound of Philadelphia, is based on the 1991 novel ‘Brotherly Love’ by former Philadelphia reporter, columnist, National Book Award-winner and screenwriter Peter Dexter. It centers on Peter (Matthias Schoenaerts), a member of the local Irish mob in Philadelphia, and his cousin Michael (Joel Kinnaman), who runs the mob with an iron fist, a position (and a trait) he inherited after the death of his father. Still reeling from the untimely death of his sister, Peter is largely disinterested in the comings and goings of Michael and the rest of the mob, more concerned with drifting in and out of his childhood hometown and reflecting on his sister’s passing, which he still feels largely responsible for. Once Michael’s attention shifts to Peter’s friends and acquaintances, including bar owner Jimmy (Paul Schneider) – who owes Michael a large sum of money – and Jimmy’s sister Grace (Maika Monroe), Peter struggles to keep the peace and defuse the tension, and he soon comes to realize that he will have to go to great lengths in order to protect his friends from his increasingly power-hungry cousin.

When we first meet Peter, he is sitting on the rooftop of a building as Jimmy recounts his experience of receiving a proctology exam, going into highly graphic detail as he recalls his feelings of fear and nervousness as a gloved nurse walked into the medical examination room. Peter may physically be there, but mentally, he is entirely elsewhere, barely reacting to Jimmy’s borderline sordid story, completely lost in thought instead. As if awakening to the reality he finds himself in, Peter suddenly rushes across the roof and jumps right off it, barely landing on his own two feet as Jimmy gasps in surprise and worry. Michael, however, is more apathetic by the sudden display he just witnessed. He is used to Peter doing things like this, he explains. And that is Peter’s character in a nutshell; unpredictable, apathetic, weighed down by feelings of grief and guilt.

A man in a boxing ring training to box.
Matthias Schoenaerts in 'Brothers By Blood' (Vertical Entertainment)

It is to the credit of Matthias Schoenaerts and his raw, searing and empathetic performance that audiences will be able to root for Peter, a character who spends the entirety of the film internalizing his feelings and choosing to suffer in silence instead. Schoenaerts has spent the bulk of his career playing characters like Peter; emotionally stunted, physically imposing men who come off as intimidating at first before their carefully constructed facades start to crack, showing the broken shell of a person that they try so hard to hide. But in the case of Peter, the facade never cracks, the cloak never lifts. Thanks to an underbaked script, we never get the opportunity to see what exactly makes Peter tick, despite the presence of flashbacks scattered throughout the film that heavy-handedly attempt to add some context to his actions – or lack thereof. In another actor’s hands, Peter could have very well been the definition of an unsympathetic character. But in Schoenaerts’ adept, careful and sensitive hands, Peter is a fully fleshed out character, one with a seemingly endless amount of baggage that Schoenaerts does a great job at communicating to audiences through mere glances in lieu of a fully fleshed out script. It is another great addition to a career full of exceptional performances for Schoenaerts.

Elsewhere, Joel Kinnaman – mostly known for playing the straight, serious foil to usually more outlandish characters – succeeds at playing against type here, delivering a menacing performance and establishing an intense, intimidating presence as the cold, ruthless Michael. Paul Schneider, who consistently delivers solid work in genre films and TV shows, manages to leave an impression as the hapless and naive Jimmy despite a lack of significant screentime, while Maika Monroe struggles to conjure up any depth in a severely underdeveloped and practically insignificant role.

Overall, Brothers By Blood mostly works as a drama thanks to a series of impeccable performances from an impressive cast that do their best to elevate a sorely underdeveloped script. A lack of set-pieces and any visual flare or style, however, renders the film mostly ineffective when it comes to the thriller aspects. Cutting in at a lean 91-minute runtime with no proper resolution, one has to wonder if certain parts or storylines were left on the cutting room floor. As it stands, however, Brothers By Blood won’t leave much of a mark on audiences but it is worth a watch thanks to strong performances from Schoenaerts, Kinnaman and Schneider alone. – Ahmad Sindi

Rating: 3/5

Brothers By Blood will be released in limited theaters and on VOD on January 22.