Interview

Peter Farrelly on I Play Rocky

Peter Farrelly discusses his new film I Play Rocky, discovering Anthony Ippolito before casting had even begun, the surprising things he learned about Sylvester Stallone, and why the actor’s refusal to compromise remains as inspiring today…

Peter Farrelly has enjoyed his fair share of extraordinary moments throughout a career that has spanned more than three decades, from the enormous commercial success of Dumb and Dumber and There’s Something About Mary to winning the Academy Award for Best Picture for Green Book. But few experiences have come close to the reception that greeted his latest film, I Play Rocky, when it made its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival in September. Playing to an audience of approximately 2,000 people, the film was met with rapturous applause throughout its runtime, with spectators cheering, laughing and occasionally erupting into applause before scenes had even finished. For Farrelly, who was understandably thrilled by the response, the experience was unlike anything he’d encountered before.

“Toronto was probably the best night of my life, business-wise, work-wise, film-wise. It was maybe everything-wise,” says Farrelly. “It was a magical night.”

“It was like being in Led Zeppelin, watching your movie being received that way,” he recalls. “I honestly felt like Robert Plant. You never get that, where the crowd just swells at several times during the show. It was just magical.”

It’s an amusing comparison, but one that perfectly captures the kind of response I Play Rocky inspires. Directed by Farrelly from a screenplay by Peter Gamble, the film chronicles the remarkable true story of how Sylvester Stallone, then a struggling actor with little to his name and an unwavering conviction in his own abilities, managed to write and star in one of the most beloved films of all time. Despite being offered considerable sums of money for his screenplay, Stallone famously refused to sell the rights unless he was allowed to portray Rocky Balboa himself, a decision that could have very easily cost him the opportunity of a lifetime but ultimately changed the course of his career.

Anthony Ippolito is phenomenal as the young Stallone, delivering an incredibly convincing, beautifully realized performance that captures the actor’s distinctive voice, mannerisms and physicality without ever descending into impersonation. He’s joined by an impressive ensemble that includes AnnaSophia Robb as Stallone’s first wife, Sasha Czack, Matt Dillon as his father, Frank Stallone Sr., P.J. Byrne and Toby Kebbell as producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff, and Jay Duplass as director John G. Avildsen. Stephan James, meanwhile, portrays Carl Weathers, with Kiki Seto taking on the role of Talia Shire, the actress who would bring Adrian Pennino to life.

The result is a wonderfully entertaining, deeply moving film that captures the enormous sacrifices Stallone made in his determination to get Rocky made, while also offering a fascinating glimpse into the chaotic and often unforgiving realities of filmmaking in 1970s Hollywood. Much like the original film, it’s an enormously satisfying underdog story, although one that becomes all the more remarkable when considering that the events depicted actually happened.

And judging by the film’s reception at Toronto, audiences appear to be just as invested in Stallone’s extraordinary journey as they were in Rocky Balboa’s nearly fifty years ago.

Farrelly has since attended screenings at other festivals, including the BFI London Film Festival and the Rome Film Festival, where he says the response has been similarly enthusiastic. While neither could quite replicate the sheer scale of the Toronto premiere, the filmmaker was particularly moved by the reaction in Rome, where an audience of approximately 700 people responded to the film with an enthusiasm he describes as almost comparable.

“It was a love fest,” he recalls. “They say we’re all the same, we’re all connected, every person. I felt that way in that room that night. Everybody was enjoying it equally at the same time.”

Much of that response can undoubtedly be attributed to Ippolito, whose extraordinary transformation into Stallone is one of the film’s greatest achievements. It’s an incredibly demanding performance, requiring the young actor to portray not only one of Hollywood’s most recognizable figures but also a character who has become almost inseparable from the actor responsible for creating him. The physical resemblance is remarkable, but what makes Ippolito’s performance so impressive is how effectively he captures Stallone’s determination, insecurity and considerable intelligence, particularly during the years before his eventual breakthrough.

Finding someone capable of doing all that might have seemed like an impossible task, particularly for a film so dependent on the authenticity of its leading performance. As it turns out, however, Farrelly and his team didn’t have to look very far. In fact, they hadn’t even started looking when Ippolito came along.

“We didn’t find Anthony. Anthony found us, and it’s the truth,” Farrelly reveals.

The production had been preparing to launch an extensive worldwide casting search, knowing that finding the right actor to portray Stallone would be essential to the film’s success. But before that process could begin, Ippolito learned about the project, managed to obtain a copy of the screenplay and decided to take matters into his own hands.

“Anthony heard about the movie, got the script, put himself on tape in his grandmother’s basement, sent it to my casting agent. My casting agent sent it to me,” Farrelly recalls. “I looked at it. I was like, ‘That’s the guy.'”

The filmmaker was immediately convinced, recognizing something in the young actor that went beyond his physical resemblance to Stallone. There was a familiarity to his movements, a confidence in his understanding of the character and, perhaps most importantly, a sense that he genuinely understood the man he was attempting to portray.

But there was one rather significant problem.

“He only weighed 145 pounds then. He was skinny,” Farrelly laughs. “The one-handed push-ups that he does in the movie? He couldn’t do three-handed push-ups when we found him.”

Fortunately, Ippolito was more than willing to put in the work. He embarked on an extensive training regimen, gaining approximately 45 pounds and learning how to box, gradually developing the physicality required to convincingly recreate some of Stallone’s most recognizable moments from the original film.

“He sounded like him and he looked like him, and he felt like him,” Farrelly explains. “So we put him in training, and he gained 45 pounds and put on muscle and learned how to box.”

It’s a particularly fascinating casting story considering how closely it mirrors the film itself. Like the young Stallone, Ippolito wasn’t prepared to sit around waiting for someone to hand him an opportunity. He knew what he wanted, believed he was capable of doing it, and took the initiative to make it happen, even when the conventional casting process hadn’t officially begun.

For Farrelly, that determination is precisely what makes Ippolito so remarkable.

“I could do a TED Talk about Anthony Ippolito because he just created his own reality,” he says. “He didn’t wait for it to happen.”

The director is also quick to dismiss the idea that he should be credited with discovering the young actor, insisting that Ippolito deserves considerably more recognition for his own achievements.

“People ask me, ‘Do you feel good that you discovered this kid?’ I said, ‘I didn’t discover him. He discovered himself.'”

That confidence also extended to Ippolito’s approach to the performance. While portraying a younger version of an established actor inevitably requires a certain amount of imitation, particularly when recreating recognizable scenes from an existing film, Farrelly understood that the performance would only work if Ippolito could distinguish between Stallone as an actual person and Rocky Balboa as a fictional character.

And it was a distinction the young actor had already mastered.

“He knew Stallone and the Rocky character better than I did,” Farrelly admits. “He was so good, and he knew the difference.”

It’s an important point, particularly because Stallone’s association with Rocky has become so deeply ingrained in popular culture that audiences often conflate the two. But for all the similarities between their respective journeys, they’re very different people, something that Farrelly was determined to communicate through the film.

“Stallone isn’t Rocky. Rocky’s a fictional character. Stallone’s a real person,” he explains.

As Farrelly points out, Rocky is written as a boxer who has spent years taking blows to the head, someone whose thoughts and reactions occasionally seem to lag behind those of the people around him. Stallone, however, is considerably more intellectually curious than the character he’s most famous for portraying.

“Rocky is a little punch-drunk. This guy has been in a lot of fights, and he’s supposed to be a tenth of a second behind everybody,” Farrelly says. “But Stallone isn’t. Stallone’s surprisingly intellectual. He’s a reader. He reads poetry. He wants to be better.”

It’s an aspect of Stallone’s personality that Ippolito captures beautifully, particularly in the scenes depicting the actor’s determination to establish himself as a writer. There’s an almost obsessive quality to his ambition, with Stallone approaching the screenplay not simply as an opportunity to land a leading role but as something deeply personal that he feels compelled to bring into existence.

For Farrelly, much of the brilliance of Ippolito’s performance lies in those subtle differences, which distinguish his portrayal from the countless impersonations of Stallone that audiences have encountered over the years.

“He captured that,” Farrelly says. “It’s a very subtle thing, but he nailed it. He didn’t do a caricature, which is the brilliance of his performance.”

And while Ippolito’s performance may be the film’s most immediately impressive achievement, I Play Rocky is also remarkable for the care with which Farrelly recreates the circumstances surrounding the original production, incorporating details that even longtime admirers of Rocky might not be familiar with.

The filmmaker spent considerable time researching Stallone’s life during the mid-1970s, including speaking with the actor himself about his experiences, his creative influences and the circumstances in which he wrote the screenplay. Some of those discoveries found their way into the film in particularly unexpected ways, including the music Stallone had been listening to while working on Rocky.

Farrelly learned that Buffalo Springfield had been among the artists accompanying Stallone during that period, a detail reflected in the film through the use of the band’s “Rock & Roll Woman” during a sequence depicting the writing process.

But one of Farrelly’s favorite discoveries involved something considerably less elaborate: a window.

While researching the circumstances in which Stallone wrote Rocky, Farrelly learned that the actor had worked on the screenplay while sitting in front of a particular window in his Los Angeles apartment. Rather than simply recreating the location on a set, the filmmaker managed to return to the original building and shoot there.

“The apartment we show, where he lives in Los Angeles, that is the apartment. That’s the place,” Farrelly reveals. “We went back to it. We shot that. We had one day to get it.”

For the director, being able to film in the very place where Stallone had written a screenplay that would eventually transform his life carried a significance that went beyond simply ensuring historical accuracy.

“The window right over the doorway was the window that he wrote in,” he explains. “There’s something about putting it in that position where, when I’m watching the movie, I feel like it’s him right at that place.”

It’s a wonderful detail, particularly for a film that takes such pleasure in exploring the process of creating something that would eventually become an essential part of cinema history. Much of the film’s appeal comes from watching the seemingly ordinary circumstances that preceded an extraordinary achievement, whether it’s Stallone sitting in his apartment working on a screenplay or struggling to convince producers that an unknown actor deserves to play the character he created.

And while the original Rocky is understandably remembered as one of the greatest sports films ever made, Farrelly is adamant that his own film isn’t really about boxing at all.

“Our movie is not a boxing movie,” he says. “It’s a movie about somebody who never sells out.”

For Farrelly, the most important part of Stallone’s story isn’t simply that he eventually became successful, but that he refused to compromise on something he believed in, even when doing so could have solved many of his immediate financial problems. Given the considerable sums of money he was being offered for the screenplay, the temptation to surrender the leading role must have been enormous, particularly for an actor who had spent years struggling to establish himself.

But Stallone remained convinced that the project would only work if he played Rocky himself, a decision that Farrelly believes reflects a much more important understanding of success than the one that often dominates contemporary discussions of wealth and achievement.

“He never took the money,” Farrelly explains. “Everybody today wants to be a billionaire, and it drives me crazy.”

The filmmaker believes that the pursuit of financial success can sometimes come at the expense of the things that make people genuinely happy, particularly when they’re encouraged to abandon their creative ambitions in favor of something more lucrative or conventional.

“If you listen to what’s in your heart, follow it, and it’s hard because it usually is risky, but if you do what’s in your heart, then you’ll find true happiness, not taking the money.”

It’s a sentiment that feels especially relevant to the story of Rocky, which has spent the past fifty years inspiring audiences to believe in themselves even when the odds seem overwhelmingly stacked against them. And while the film’s enormous cultural impact is now impossible to deny, it’s worth remembering that Stallone had no way of knowing whether his gamble would pay off when he first refused to surrender the role.

That uncertainty is something Farrelly understands particularly well. Before establishing himself as a filmmaker, he had pursued a considerably different path, studying accounting in college without any particular intention of becoming a writer.

“I was an accounting major in college, and it never even occurred to me to write until I was well into my twenties,” he recalls. “And then suddenly, I started thinking a lot, ‘I should have been a writer,’ and I was barely a reader.”

It’s an interesting admission from someone who would eventually become one of the most commercially successful comedy filmmakers of his generation, particularly when considering how much of his career has been defined by an ability to recognize the potential in ideas that might seem unconventional or unlikely to succeed.

When asked about the significance of telling Stallone’s story at a time when technology, particularly artificial intelligence, is changing the way art is created and consumed, Farrelly admits that he hadn’t previously considered the film from that perspective. But he is enthusiastic about the idea that creativity can emerge from the most unexpected places, and that people shouldn’t necessarily feel restricted by their backgrounds, circumstances or the expectations of those around them.

“I love the idea that you don’t know where art is gonna come from,” he explains.

For Farrelly, the young Stallone represents a particularly wonderful example of that unpredictability. Here was a struggling actor who was frequently dismissed because of his appearance, voice and unconventional screen presence, yet somehow managed to write a screenplay that not only launched his career but went on to become one of the most enduring works in American cinema.

“You don’t know, until you follow what’s in your heart, you don’t know what you can become,” Farrelly says.

And perhaps what he finds most remarkable is that the film Stallone created has continued to resonate with audiences long after its original release, its themes of perseverance, self-belief and determination proving just as powerful today as they were in 1976.

“I love the idea that a Stallone who’s perceived as just a big, thuggy guy at that time could write something that we’re still talking about fifty years later,” he says. “And they will still be talking about it if we’re here in another fifty years.”

I PLAY ROCKY is now playing in select US theaters and expands nationwide on November 20.